Musician by training – Musician by intuition

First published in Katalogen 2010, issued for Trygve Madsen’s seventieth birthday by Musikk-Husets Forlag A/S, pp. 10–11. English translation: Andrew Smith. © 2010 Musikk-Husets Forlag A/S.

This is an archival text from 2010. Dates, roles and descriptions reflect the time of publication.

Thore Hansen’s illustrated score cover for Variations and Fugue on a Theme by Beethoven, Op. 28.
Cover illustration: Thore Hansen (1982). Inset portrait source unknown. From Variations and Fugue on a Theme by Beethoven, Op. 28, reproduced in Katalogen 2010, Musikk-Husets Forlag A/S. Source catalogue

At best a musician is a co-creating, communicating aesthete who does his utmost to convey his art to an audience; at worst he risks becoming a dry, dogmatic know-it-all with boundless faith in his knowledge. A true musician, however, manages to retain a playful, childlike delight in music as a phenomenon, and is therefore just as well equipped to communicate with his audience as is the trained intellectual. What such a true musician might lack in intellectual insight he makes up for in the way he communicates.

Trygve Madsen is not simply a musician – he is an intuitive communicator, a truly musical person. It goes without saying that these two types of musical character must produce an optimal mix. In Trygve’s case the ingredients consist of a rock-solid formal expertise on the one hand, and effervescent playfulness on the other. Those of us who have had the pleasure of performing several of his works are constantly struck by the vitality and genuineness of his compositional craft, and, even more importantly: his music lives a life of its own to a degree seldom experienced in contemporary art forms. The music is strong willed, characteristic and symptomatic of its originator – full of poetry and humour.

In our time, the public debate has for a number of generations been characterized by an anxiety on the part of creative artists for not being original enough. In many cases this has led to a fascinating paradox: in fear of sounding or looking like their predecessors, artists have instead begun to sound or look like each other, and that to a degree which has assumed almost absurd proportions. The idea that certain styles of musical language should be better or more modern than others, has always had a clammy feeling of cultural fascism about it; this has been a costly impediment to the creative process. Many talented composers – both in Norway and the world in general – have given in to the unrelenting pressure of «– isms», some by submitting to the tyranny of the spirit of the age, others by giving up their art altogether. This has contributed to creating a false impression of modernistic homogeneity in which the aim has been to determine a degree of acceptable modernity from individual components, most notably the degree of tonal dissolution.

Sixty years of Darmstadt summer courses have shown that musical modernity or originality does not depend on whether or not one abolishes some formula or other, or a physical aspect of art (such as form, tonality or types of instrument), but resides entirely in the music’s ability to communicate. In other words: any discussion in which it is claimed that C major is old-fashioned and atonality is modern, is out of date. After all, it is nearly a hundred years since The Rite of Spring was first performed.

This is also true of a debate on art in which there has been an increasing tendency to equate musical genres and concepts of quality; no matter where one was located in the wider musical terrain, all other styles of music were considered inferior – classically trained musicians were therefore programmed to detest rock, rock musicians hated classical, jazz musicians could not stand pop, and everybody despised folk music. Today we see music academy students excelling in several areas –contemporary music composers, rock musicians and classical specialists are on speaking terms and even discuss things over a cappuccino in the cantina. What has happened? It is simple – dogmatism is dead, for musical communication cannot be eradicated.

In this context Trygve Madsen is nothing less than a leading light – he has broadcast his harmonic trumpet fanfares out into the cultural fog and stayed true to his characteristic style no matter what the spirit of the age (or lack of) might have been. Thus he has achieved something which is both fantastic and inevitable: he is genuinely original! His music is unmistakable from the very first bar, giving the performer confidence and a sense of familiarity in the musical landscape – where there are inner correlations between a composer’s works this gives a performer considerable authority based on his or her experience with previous works. An authoritative performer will be able to give a liberated, co-creative performance – if he feels that the music makes him «good», he will play well.

Madsen the intuitive musician understands what it takes to make musicians good, and many of them are interested in performing his music. There is therefore nothing remarkable in the fact that his music is performed all over the world, and that many of his works have become set pieces. He also presents something of his personality in his music – many of us have fallen for his verbal wit, a quality which we find in the creative process and which testifies to more than just generosity – it testifies also to courage.

Madsen the trained musician is a fount of knowledge: there are few who can match his historical, technical and cultural insight into all matters musical.

Trygve’s music is a living organism; his training allows him to obtain the requisite musical skeleton with all its complex formal qualities and necessities – whereas his intuition provides the skeleton with muscle, skin and beauty. These two elements are therefore crucial in bringing the musical organism to life, but there is no life without spirit: the spirit is the composer’s own.